Garmin

Garmin Vivosmart 5

Ranked #15 in Fitness Trackers

0 LP on the category ladder what's LP?

The outclassed old-timer. It is still on shelves and still pushed by roundups, but it is an aging design that Garmin's own current all-rounder has leapfrogged. Buy the Garmin Vivoactive 6 instead.

Consolidated from 7 independent outlets

Where the cited sources landed, as we read them

6 positive sources
1 mixed source

See the sources

Flagged as a product to avoid

6 of 17 research runs entered this as a product to avoid rather than a pick.

Aging design outclassed by Garmin's current all-rounder, the Vivoactive 6.
Flagged 18 October 2026

2 earlier flags predate the point where runs began recording their reasoning, so their grounds were never written down.

Aging design outclassed by Garmin's current all-rounder, the Vivoactive 6.
Flagged 18 October 2026
An older-generation Garmin band kept alive by one budget blog's legacy recommendation; the major current testing outlets have all dropped it from their recommendations.
Flagged 18 October 2026
2021 hardware with no successor, a small dated screen, and a feature set the Charge 6 and Vivoactive 6 have long since passed. Garmin loyalists cross-shop it on brand trust alone.
Flagged 18 October 2026
A 2022-era band that current expert testing has largely passed over, still selling on the Vivosmart name while the Charge 6 and Galaxy Fit 3 do more for similar money. Buy the Charge 6.
Flagged 18 October 2026

Why the boards include products to avoid

Check price

Pros & cons

✓ Competitive core tracking
✓ Garmin ecosystem connectivity
✓ Long battery life
✓ Still crowned Best Overall on the My Smart Buy Review 2026 list
✓ Slim everyday band form factor

✗ Hardware is visibly dated next to newer budget bands
✗ Older-generation design
✗ Dropped from the current recommendations of the major testing outlets
✗ 2021 hardware
✗ No successor model

The sources behind this ranking

We searched the web and YouTube for what has been published about this product, then read the articles, video transcripts and comments we found.

Evidence 1 article and 6 video reviews

6 positive sources

SmartBuyReview Article · Oct 2026

The Garmin Vivosmart 5 is widely regarded by industry experts as the gold standard for those who want a dedicated tracker without the bulk of a full-fledged smartwatch. Based on our research, it excels at providing granular data through the Garmin Connect ecosystem, which remains one of the most comprehensive platforms for visualizing movement and intensity levels. The device features a crisp OLED display and a physical button that many users find more reliable than touch-only interfaces during sweaty workout sessions. Pros: Excellent battery life, highly accurate movement tracking, and a robust app interface. The silicone band is replaceable, which adds to the longevity of the hardware.

Read T The Product Reviewer The Product Reviewer · 24.7K subscribers · May 2022

There we have the Garmin Vivosmart 5 which is arguably the best fitness tracker in 2022 (so far). Not only do we get an Oled screen but this one is also water resistant up to 5 atm, it has a music player, you receive notifications to which you can actually reply and a lot more awsome stuff

Watch F Fitness With Frost Fitness With Frost · 10.2K subscribers · May 2022

you do get respiratory rate on the vivosmart 5 that's why you're going to get a more accurate sleep score and that's why this is going to be better for your sleep tracking you're also going to get some other things like a calendar on the 5 you also get some real-time syncing to the connect app where you actually have to upload it manually with the vivosmart 4.

Watch S Super Simple Fixes Super Simple Fixes · 7.7K subscribers · Jun 2023

Honestly, as a crossfitter, I could not be happier with the Garmin Vivosmart 5!!!

Watch U

Universe3d Universe3d · 3K subscribers · Jun 2026

It's my new go-to recommendation for anyone seeking a serious fitness tracker that doesn't compromise on style.

Watch T Tech Neon Tech Neon · 5 subscribers · Nov 2023

So, what are my final thoughts on the Garmin Vivosmart 5? It's a top-tier fitness tracker that excels in design, accuracy, and functionality. Whether you're a fitness enthusiast or someone looking to improve their overall health, the Vivosmart 5 is up for the task. It offers a seamless blend of style and substance, making it a standout choice in the world of fitness trackers

Watch

1 mixed source

Verified Reviews Verified Reviews · 1.3K subscribers · Jul 2026

Garmin Vivosmart 5 isn't a disaster, far from it, but it's not a powerhouse smartwatch, and some of its features can feel half-baked or underwhelming. Ultimately, do I recommend the Garmin Vivosmart 5? For casual users seeking a reliable, stylish, and simple fitness tracker with solid battery life, yes. But if you want a serious health monitoring device, a vibrant responsive screen, or true GPS independence, you might want to consider other options

Watch

Frequently asked questions

It ranks #15 of 16 on our fitness trackers tier list, in F tier. That placement draws on 7 independent outlets.

None of the 7 sources with a clear view is critical of it. Hardware is visibly dated next to newer budget bands. Older-generation design. Dropped from the current recommendations of the major testing outlets. 2021 hardware. No successor model.

On our fitness trackers board, Fitbit Charge 6 ranks #1 (S tier) ahead of Garmin Vivosmart 5 at #15 (F tier). Fitbit Charge 6: CNET's current best fitness tracker overall with a proven multi-year track record the newest models cannot yet show. Slightly behind the Charge 7 only because its firmware clock started earlier.

On our fitness trackers board, Fitbit Inspire 3 ranks #2 (S tier) ahead of Garmin Vivosmart 5 at #15 (F tier). Fitbit Inspire 3: Years on sale with a public, reliable failure record and near-universal recommendation make it the known quantity of the budget tier and the smartest buy in the category for most people.