Lodge

Lodge Blacklock 12 Inch Cast-Iron Skillet

Ranked #12 in Cast Iron Skillets

68 LP on the category ladder what's LP?

While generally well-regarded for its smoother surface, some owners report the handle’s discomfort over long sessions and consider replacing it.

Consolidated from 5 independent outlets

Where the cited sources landed, as we read them

See the sources

Flagged as a product to avoid

6 of 7 research runs entered this as a product to avoid rather than a pick.

Although similar to the 10.25-inch version, the larger size adds weight and can be more prone to uneven seasoning over time; several reviewers have reported that it requires more frequent re-seasoning than its smaller counterpart.
Flagged 26 July 2026

Although similar to the 10.25-inch version, the larger size adds weight and can be more prone to uneven seasoning over time; several reviewers have reported that it requires more frequent re-seasoning than its smaller counterpart.
Flagged 26 July 2026
Its larger size adds weight without proportional benefit, and it is priced higher than the 10.25-inch counterpart.
Flagged 26 July 2026
Premium price for a larger surface that does not justify the cost; better to choose the 10.25-inch version.
Flagged 26 July 2026
Handle becomes uncomfortable during extended use, leading to discussions about aftermarket handle replacements.
Flagged 6 August 2026
Higher incidence of warping and uneven seasoning compared to the Chef Collection, leading to more frequent repairs or replacements; warranty does not cover these cosmetic issues.
Flagged 25 July 2026
Overpriced for its weight; no performance gain over the 10.25-inch model.
Flagged 25 July 2026

Why the boards include products to avoid

Check price

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.

Pros & cons

✓ Smoother surface
✓ Large cooking surface
✓ Good heat retention
✓ Even heating
✓ Sturdy build

✗ Uncomfortable handle during extended use
✗ Potential need for replacement
✗ Heavier and less even seasoning
✗ Requires more frequent re-seasoning
✗ Heavy for its size

The sources behind this ranking

We searched the web and YouTube for what has been published about this product, then read the articles, video transcripts and comments we found. 3 outlets wouldn't let us check their links.

5 stance not read sources

Bon Appetit Article Read W

Wirecutter Article Read S

Serious Eats Article Read F

Food & Wine Article Read M

monster.com Article Read

Frequently asked questions

It ranks #12 (F tier) on our consolidated cast iron skillets board, drawn from 5 independent outlets.

Uncomfortable handle during extended use. Potential need for replacement. Heavier and less even seasoning. Requires more frequent re-seasoning. Heavy for its size.